877.222.4542

Batavia Office (formerly Stephen Hawley & Assoc.)

In 1991, Stephen M. Hawley & Assoc. in Batavia, NY purchased the Sherwin Agency and then merged with Great Lakes Insurance in Spring 2020.  The Sherwin Agency, founded in 1867 by Sidney A. Sherwin, was one of the oldest insurance agencies in N.Y. State. Since...

North Hills Office

Since 1969, Great Lakes Insurance has been committed to giving businesses and families peace of mind through the best possible coverage at the lowest price available. No risk is too challenging as we represent over 100 carriers both on the national and regional level....

Salamanca Office (formerly Gary Brown Agency)

Previously known as the Gary C. Brown Agency with two locations in New York, one in Salamanca, and the other in Randolph, The Gary Brown Agency was purchased by the Great Lakes Insurance parent company in 2012. Since 1969, Great Lakes Insurance has committed to giving...

Randolph Office (formerly Gary Brown Agency)

Previously known as the Gary C. Brown Agency with two locations in New York, one in Salamanca, and the other in Randolph, The Gary Brown Agency was purchased by the Great Lakes Insurance parent company in 2012. Since 1969, Great Lakes Insurance has committed to giving...